Best Muffin Pan: Reviews and Buying Guide 2020

Are you tired of buying muffins for breakfast? Want to taste one that has your favorite ingredients in it? Tried making some but could not get them perfectly round? Then what you need is a muffin pan.

However, with all the models that many different manufacturers are offering in the market, it would be quite challenging for someone to settle on the best muffin pan among all of them.

Well, you will not have to worry about that anymore because we are here for that. We are not only going to make it easy for you to choose one of the units but also will provide you an elaborate buying guide and let you know all the things that you should know about making muffins and maintaining your pan.

Why Muffin Pan Should Be a Good Choice?

While there are a plethora of ways to bake muffins on, however, these are the reasons why you should consider investing on one:

Perfection

Yes, you will be able to bake muffins on other cooking surfaces than pan using some techniques, but you will have a tough time getting them risen perfectly and round. What you are going to need for getting those is a pan.

A Muffin Pan

Other than that, it will also ensure that they are brown and are perfectly cooked from all sides. So for perfectly baked muffins, you should opt for one of these.

Versatility

Even though the name of the pan might give you an idea that they are only used for baking muffins, but that is not the case with these. They are exceptionally versatile, and you will be able to bake cupcakes, buns, egg sandwiches, and many other pastries.

It will let you upgrade your bakery game and have a plethora of delicious bakery items in your table.

Top 10 Best Muffin Pan Reviews 

As we said, the market is full of options in the case of muffin pans, and it would be quite easy for you to get baffled among all of them while trying to choose one for your baking needs.

And, for making the choosing process easier for you, we went through the most popular ones and made a list with only the ones that stood out the most to us. Have a look at the list that we huddled for you:

1. CHEFMADE Muffin Cake Pan

CHEFMADE Muffin Cake Pan

Distributing even heat to the doughs is one of the main tasks of a pan. And this one that CHEFMADE is offering in the market excels in that.

The unit utilizes a thick 0.8 millimeters carbon steel that will make sure that the heat is distributed evenly on the surface. Because of that, you will be able to get perfectly brown and the right texture on your muffin. You will not have to worry about uncooked parts anymore.

Alongside that, this steel also ensures that the unit does not warp over time. This durable material will expand the overall lifespan. That means it will last for an extended amount of time without showing any issues.

It also adopts a non-stick silicone coating on the surface that is food-grade. Because of being food-grade, it is entirely safe for being heated up in extreme temperatures. You will not have to worry about it releasing harmful chemicals in high temperatures as it is PTFE and PFOA free.

This non-stick coating will let you bake using a low amount of oil. You will be able to get perfectly cooked cakes on it with just brushing a little amount of oil on the surface. It also lowers the time required for baking and the consumption of energy.

The non-Teflon surface will also make it easier for you to keep it clean. Residues do not stick on it, and you will be able to get them off with just a simple rinse. That means keeping it clean will not be any hassle at all.

There are four different slot options. It ranges from six cups to twenty cups. With them, you will be able to bake at large quantities in a short amount of time. You will be able to make your tea parties more exciting by including more bakery items in the table.

Pros

  • Distributes heat evenly on the surface
  • Features a sturdy carbon steel body
  • Easy to maintain
  • It takes a short amount of time to bake
  • Has a food-grade non-stick surface

Cons

  • Color from the side surface chips over time
  • Mini model can not make the muffins rise properly

2. Sweese 517.101 Porcelain Muffin Pan

Sweese 517.101 Porcelain Muffin Pan

Most of the pans that are out there that are of long-lasting lasting material are not a hundred percent free from toxic chemicals. However, you will not have to worry about that if you get this one.

The unit is of durable porcelain material. That means it will not only last for an extended amount of time but also will be resistant to stains, chipping, cracking, and scratches. You can expect it to remain in the same state as it came out of the package for a good amount of time.

Apart from being just durable, it is also completely free from toxic materials. It is lead-free, and the ceramic is of non-toxic type. You will not have to worry about it releasing harmful chemicals to your food when you turn the temperature all the way up. It is microwave-safe and oven-safe.

Like most of the units, it also comes with a non-stick surface on the top. This non-stick surface will not only reduce the use of cooking oil and the time required to bake but also make sure that you do not have any trouble in taking the muffin out of the slots when it is fully baked.

Alongside that, the non-stick surface will also make it easier for you to keep the unit clean. The residues do not get embedded on the surface, and you will be able to take them off with a simple rinse. You will also be able to clean it using a dishwasher as it is dishwasher and broiler safe.

The unit comes with six slots that will let you cook six muffins in one go. That means you will be able to bake for a large number of people.

Pros

  • Features a non-toxic and lead-free body
  • Has non-stick coating on the surface
  • Resistant to stains and chipping
  • Easy to clean
  • Take a little amount of time to bake

Cons

  • Slots are relatively narrower
  • Muffins tend not to rise that much on the slots

3. Cuisinart AMB-12MP Chef's Classic Nonstick Bakeware

Cuisinart AMB-12MP Chef's Classic Nonstick Bakeware

The manufacturer Cuisinart has been around for quite a while now. They are one of the manufacturers that has been providing quality kitchen equipment in the market. And this one is one of them.

Unlike most of the units that are out there, you will have three different options in the case of exterior color. You will be able to choose from silver, champagne, and bronze. That means you will not have to worry about the unit looking out of place among all your other kitchen wares.

Alongside that, you will also have three different size options. There is a mini version that has six cup slots, which is ideal for personal use. You can also opt for the 12 cups and 24 cups version if you want to bake for a large number of people at one go.

All the pans are of aluminum steel. This heavy-gauge will make sure that the heat is evenly distributed to the dough, and it gets cooked to perfection. You are sure to have a perfectly brown surface on your bakery items if you bake on this unit.

It also has a Xylan non-stick surface on both the exterior and the interior of the cup slots. For that coating, you will have no trouble in the case of taking the food out of the slots.

Alongside that, it will also make it easier for you to keep the unit clean. The residues can be cleaned with just a wipe. You can also put it inside a dishwasher for hassle-free cleaning experience.

As the edges have thick rolling, you will also not have to worry about warping. You can expect it to last for an extended amount of time and provide you with evenly cooked muffins every time.

Pros

  • Comes in three different colors
  • Has 6, 12, and 24 cup slots options
  • Features a heavy-gauge aluminum body
  • Thick edges prevent warping
  • Dishwasher-safe and easy to clean

Cons

  • Requires a good amount of cooking oil
  • Non-stick coating is not that efficient

4. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick, Set of 2

Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick, Set of 2

Do you know what is better than having just one pan? Two of them! And you will not have to get the other one separately if you opt for the set that Wilton is offering here.

As we mentioned, the package comes with two individual pans. Each of them has six cup slots. The cups are 3.5x1.75 inches. That means you will be able to bake twelve muffins at one. With that, you will have no hassles at all in the case of preparing bakery items for a large number of people.

Keeping the tabs up with the rest of the units, it also comes with a non-stick coating on the surface. This coating will not only make it easier for you to take the food out of the slots but also will allow you to clean the unit easily.

As it is a dishwasher-safe ware, you will be able to keep it clean easily. However, if you want to clean it properly, you have to clean it with your hands.

The overall construction of the unit is quite sturdy as well. It features a heavy-gauge aluminum body that is durable. This construction will help in distributing the heat evenly, which means you will be able to get a proper brown surface on your food quickly. The thick edges will make sure that it does not warp over time.

Other than that, it also comes in two different size options. You will be able to choose from 6 cups or 12 cups slot designs. The units come with oversized handles that will make it easier for you to maneuver it in the oven and the microwave.

Pros

  • Packages include two individual pans
  • Durable overall construction
  • Available in six cups or twelve cup slots
  • Easy to maintain
  • Oversized handles for easy maneuvering

Cons

  • Catches rust at the weld seam
  • Non-stick coating loses efficiency over time

5. Rachael Ray 54075 Yum -o Nonstick Bakeware

Rachael Ray 54075 Yum -o Nonstick Bakeware

Getting pans out of the oven wearing oven mitts can be a bit tricky because you do not really get that much amount of grip with those. Rachel Ray understood that and implemented a convenient feature on the handle to mitigate that.

Let us talk about the highlighting feature first. The handles that the unit comes with have grippy pads on them. These pads will make sure that you get more than enough grip while holding the entire pan that is full of food.

You will not have to worry about accidentally dropping the entire thing that much.

The manufacturer did not skimp one bit in the overall construction as well. It features a heavy-gauge steel body that is exceptionally sturdy. The body can also withstand extreme temperatures and has a rating of being oven-safe for up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Its sturdy frame also resists warping, which means you will be able to use it for an extended amount of time.

Like most of the units that are out there, this one also features a non-stick coating on the exterior. However, unlike some of the pans, this coating will not fade away quickly.

It ensures an easy food pickup and also makes the cleaning process a bit easier. Also, you will not require that much amount of cooking oil to bake on it.

Talking about the cleaning procedure, it is also dishwasher-safe. That means you will be able to get those excess residues off the surface quickly. It comes in three different cup options.

You will be able to choose from six, twelve, and twenty-four cups configuration. With the twenty-four one, you can cook for a large-sized group withing in one go.

Pros

  • Features grippy pads on the handle
  • Easy to maneuver
  • Comes in three different sizes
  • Efficient and long-lasting non-stick coating
  • Has a sturdy body

Cons

  • Produces a strong rubber smell after heating it up
  • Cup slots are for mini muffins

6. USA Pan (1200MF) Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin

USA Pan (1200MF) Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin

As we mentioned above, muffin pans are exceptionally versatile, and you can cook many other things on it. Keeping that factor in mind, if you were in the lookout for the best muffin pan for cake, then this is one the one that you should consider.

Apart from the versatility that it has to offer, it also comes packed with a durable body. It is of aluminized steel that is of heavy-gauge. That means it will be able to last for an extended amount of time without showing any signs of warping or anything of that sort.

 Unlike most of the units that are out there, this one comes with proper-sized wells. The slots are for standard-sized muffins, and you will be able to bake big sized cupcakes on it too.

There are two different size options. You will be able to choose from twelve slots and twenty-four slots. However, the twenty-four slot version only has mini-muffin well size.

The unit comes featured with a proprietary coating on the surface. This Americoat coating is just another type of non-stick coating. Because of that, you will be able to get your food out of the wells quickly, and alongside that, it will also make it easier for you to get the residues off the surface.

Other than that, it comes with a fluted design that will enhance the non-stick characteristics even further. It will also distribute the heat evenly on the wells and make sure that your food cooks appropriately in them.

You will not have to worry about the silicone coating, releasing any harmful chemicals as it is PFOA, PTFE, and BPA free. That means you will be able to use it for cooking in ovens without any issues at all.

Pros

  • Exceptionally versatile
  • Features a heavy-gauge aluminized steel body
  • Distributes the heat evenly
  • Comes in two different sizes
  • Has a non-stick coating on the surface

Cons

  • Twenty-four cup option has small wells
  • Non-stick surface starts to chip off over time

7. Baker's Advantage 5111815

Baker's Advantage 5111815

Baking is all fun and all, but cleaning the wares after enjoying your food is a tedious task. Well, you will not have to worry about that if you opt for this pan that is from Baker’s Advantage, which does have some advantages over the other units.

To start with, it comes with a large body that has twenty-four wells in it. That means you will be able to bake for a good amount of people, and you will have no delays at all at bringing out the bakery items to the party that you are going to host.

The slots have a consistent depth from one to another, which means all your food items will have a uniform size.

Other than that, as the body is of 0.4 millimeters thick carbon steel, you will not have to worry that much the durability too. It will work optimally for an extended amount of time. Because of the thick edges, it will also not show any signs of warping over time.

It is infused with silicone on the surface that will make sure that the heat distribution is even and your food gets cooked properly. The surface is also PFOA free, which means you will not have to worry about it releasing harmful chemicals when you heat it up.

Alongside that, the silicone infusion also acts as a non-stick coating. The coating is on both the front and the back of the unit. It will let you easily take your food off the wells. As it is dishwasher-safe, you will not have to worry that much about the cleaning procedure too. The coating also helps in taking the residues off the surface.

Pros

  • Easy to clean
  • Conducts and distributes heat evenly
  • Features a durable carbon steel construction
  • Has twenty-four consistently sized wells
  • Silicone PFOA free non-stick coating on both sides

Cons

  • Some units ships with machine oils on the wells
  • Tends to catch rust over time

8. Trudeau Structured Silicone Muffin Pan

Trudeau Structured Silicone Muffin Pan

Even though most of the steel pans feature a non-stick coating that makes it easier to pick the food from the surface, but you know what will make it easier? Silicone wells that you can push from the bottom. Well, Trudeau got you covered if you were searching for one of them.

As we mentioned, the wells are of silicone. This silicone slot does not only help in taking the food out of it but also makes it exceptionally easy to maneuver because of the flexibility. It is relatively lighter than the steel counterparts, and you will be able to handle it with just a single hand even with food on it.

Other than that, the silicone wells also offer efficient non-stick properties that steel ones fail to provide. Because of that, it gains an exceptional amount of versatility. It is also probably the best muffin pan for eggs that we have in this list. You will also be able to cook cupcakes on it.

As it features a silicone body, you might think it will not be able to retain its shape. Well, that will not be the case because it has a steel frame that will allow it to stay flat.

The steel frame will also make it easier for you to maneuver it around. Also, there are grippy pads on the handles that will make the task of taking it out of the smoother.

It can also distribute the heat evenly to every well even if it is not of steel. As the silicone is of FDA grade, you will not have to worry about it releasing toxins too. It will also not have the burning smell that most of the wares of this material tend to output.

Pros

  • Easy to take the food out
  • Exceptionally versatile
  • Non-toxic FDA approved silicone body
  • Retains its shape
  • Lightweight and easy to maneuver

Cons

  • The size of the wells is relatively small
  • Not that easy to clean

9. Circulon 46014 Nonstick Bakeware

Circulon 46014 Nonstick Bakeware

Most of the units in the market will come with steel construction. However, the part where most fails to deliver is warp-resistance. But if you get this one that is from Circulon, you will not have to worry about that.

First of all, the unit comes featured with a heavy-gauge steel body that is not only sturdy but also is resistant to warping. That means you will not have to worry about it warping over time. You can expect it to last for an extended amount of time.

As the unit features twelve wells for the muffins, you will be able to bake for a large number of people at one go. The rolled-rim that it features on the handles will make it easier for you to handle it.

You will be able to get a good grasp of the handles while taking it from the oven and putting it inside it. They are wide enough that you will be able to maneuver it safely, even if you have oven mitts on.

It also features raised circles on each of the wells. That, combined with the premium non-stick coating, will make it easier for you to take the food off the surface. It also will make it easier for you to get the food residues off the surface. As the unit is dishwasher safe, you will not have to worry about the cleaning procedure too.

There are three different color options that you will be able to choose from. One of them is the chocolate color that will go well with chocolate cupcakes. The other ones are gray and merlot. They will blend exceptionally well with the rest of your kitchen wares.

Pros

  • Features a heavy-gauge steel body
  • Resistant to warping
  • Has wide, rolled-rim handles
  • Wells have a non-stick coating and raised design
  • Easy to clean and easy to maneuver

Cons

  • Non-stick coating can be scraped off easily
  • Some units ship with dents on the body

10. Farberware 47742 Nonstick Bakeware

Farberware 47742 Nonstick Bakeware

We are going to finish off muffin pan reviews with this set that Farberware is offering. Yes, it is a set. You are going to get two units with this one.

The manufacturer Farberware is known for offering heavy-duty kitchen wares. And they did not lower down on that with this set. Each of the units comes with sturdy aluminum construction.

It will be able to withstand the demanding pressure that heavy-duty kitchen tasks usually exert.

Also, the durable body will ensure that it does not warp over time. You can expect it to last for an extended amount of time.

As you are getting two of the units, you will be able to bake twenty-four cakes in total. That means baking for a large number of people will not be any hassle at all.

Each of the wells ensures that the heat is distributed correctly to the entire dough, which will make sure that you have an even brown color on the surface. Alongside that, the even heat distribution will also lower the chances of burning your food.

It also comes with a non-stick coating on the surface. This coating will not only make it easier for you to release the food from the wells but also will make it much easier for you to clean it. You will not have to worry about food residues getting embedded on the surface.

The handles that the units feature is quite wide too. You will be able to get a firm grasp of it even if you have oven mitts on your hands. These handles make it easier to handle the units.

Pros

  • Comes in a set of two
  • Features over-sized handles
  • Easy to maneuver and easy to clean
  • Has a non-stick coating
  • Ensures even distribution of heat

Cons

  • Non-stick coating chips over time
  • Not dishwasher-safe

What to Look for While Buying a Muffin Pan?

After going through the reviews, you might already have a general idea about what you can expect from a decent pan. But to solidify that even more and to ensure that you make an efficient decision, we are here to provide you some factors that you should keep in mind before you invest your money in one of them:

Build Quality

The first thing that you have to consider is the overall build quality. Most of the units will feature an aluminum body or a steel one. For those, what you have to check is if they come with thick edges or not.

If that is missing, the unit might warp over time, and you would not want that to happen to your essential kitchen wares, would you?

Muffin Pan

The case is a bit different for the ones that come with a silicone body. Those will not warp as they are made from silicone. But for those, you have to consider whether they have a steel frame inside or not. Without that, they will not be able to retain their shape, and also, you will not be able to maneuver them properly.

Handles

Handles are one of the crucial parts of pans. What you have to consider in this case is the size of them. If the units do not come with wide handles, you will not be able to have a good grasp.

Besides that, many do come with relatively narrower handles, but they have some sort of rubber grips on the top. So you should factor that in if you are shooting for the ones that have narrow handles.

Size

The size is another thing that you have to consider before making a purchase. In this case, the first thing that you have to factor in is the number of slots that the unit has.

If you plan to use it for baking in low quantities, then the six cups option that most of the units come with should be more than enough. But if you plan to bake in large numbers, you should look for something that has 12 or 24 slots.

Other than that, you should also factor in the size of the wells too. Even though most of the 24 cups one is for mini muffins, but if you want to bake the regular sized ones then you should go for the ones that have standard-sized slots.

However, not all the 24 slot options will come with standard-sized wells. For those, we would suggest you to opt for two 12 slot ones.

Coating

Nearly all the units that are in the market will come with a non-stick coating on the surface. However, the thing that you have to consider in this is the quality of the coating.

If the coating is not that durable, it will wear off over time. And if it does chip off over time, you will not be able to get the same baking experience that you had from it after you took it out of the package.

Alongside that, you should also make sure that the coating does not emit any harmful toxins once you heat the unit up.

Heat Distribution

You will also have to factor in the ability of the unit's heat distribution. If the one that you are shooting for can not distribute the heat properly in the wells, you will be left with baked items that will have burnt spots, and you would not want that happen to the dough that you put so much effort on.

That is why you should make sure that the pan can distribute the heat evenly in the slots.

Cleaning Procedure

The last thing that you have to consider is the cleaning procedure of the units. If you want a hassle-free cleaning experience, we would suggest you opt for the ones that are dishwasher safe.

Other than that, you should also make sure that the non-stick coating is efficient, or else you are going to have a tough time taking the food residues off the surface.

How to Make Muffins with a Muffin Pan?

Baking muffins is as easy as it sounds, and we are going to make that task easier for you by providing you seven simple steps that are quite easy to follow. They are:

Make Muffins with a Muffin Pan

Step 1: Preparation

First, you have to preheat the oven. Turn the temperature up to 375 degrees and let it preheat. In the meantime, you will have to prepare the pan by spraying cooking oils or putting paper liners on the cup slots. Alongside that, you should also gather the ingredients that you wish to use for the baking.

Step 2: Mixing the Dry Ingredients

After you have prepared all the pan and preheated the oven, you will have to mix all the baking ingredients. Add sugar, salt, baking powder, and flour together. Set the mixed bowl aside and move on to the next step.

Step 3: Mixing the Wet Ingredients

Now, you will have to get some oil, egg, vanilla essence, and milk.  Mix all of them together in a medium-sized bowl and set it aside.

Step 4: Mixing the Wet and Dry Ingredients Together

After that, you will have to get back to the dry ingredients. Gently pour the mixed wet ingredients on the bowl that you mixed the dry ingredients together.

While you are pouring the liquid, you will have to stir the ingredients around with a rubber or wooden spatula. Stir until you get a good consistency. You might have some lumps, which is absolutely fine.

Step 5: Mix Other Ingredients

Most of the people like to use chocolate chips and nuts in the muffins. And, if you want to add any mix-ins, now is the perfect time for that. Drizzle them on the dour and fold it around with the spatula. Four to five folds should be enough to get all the mix-ins distributed.

Step 6: Fill Up the Wells and Put It Inside the Oven

Now, you will have to divide the mixed batter into the muffin pan. Depending on the size of the wells, you will have to put about 1/3 cup of mixed batter per well. After they are filled up, you will have to put it inside the oven. Bake it till you can see golden brown exterior on the top. It should take about 20 minutes.

Step 7: Take the Pan Out

After they are properly baked, you will have to take it out. To test the dough, you can insert a toothpick in one of them and pull it out. The toothpick should come out clean if the dough is adequately cooked.

How to Clean a Muffin Pan?

Now that you have enjoyed freshly-baked muffins, you would want to know how to clean them. Well, we got you covered in that regard too.

For the Dishwasher-Safe Pans

If you have a pan that is dishwasher safe, you will not have to go through that much of a hassle. Just put the pan inside the dishwasher and wait for a bit. After the dishwasher is done with the cleaning task, take the pan out and put it on your sink.

Clean a Muffin Pan

Then you will have to rinse and scrub the entire pan for a while. Take a sponge and soak it a bit with dish soap. Go through each of the wells and clean the upper surface too. If you can see that the dishwasher could not wipe the food residues properly, you might have to scrub it vigorously.

For the Normal Pans

First, you will have to get all the materials. You will need a sponge or a scrubber. We would recommend you to go for the ones that do not have any metal parts in them because those can scratch the surface of your pan. Then you will need dishwashing soap and a bit of baking soda.

Mix two tablespoons of baking soda in 1-quart warm water and pour it on top of the pan. Then you will have to put the pan inside the oven for about 20 minutes. After that, you will have to take it out and let it cool for a while.

Then you will have to scrub the surface with soap and a scrubber. Rinse it properly after scrubbing, and you will have a squeaky clean pan.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is there any difference between a muffin and a cupcake pan?

Yes, some differences do set both of them apart. One of that is that the muffin pans sometimes have deeper wells and have straight sides while the cupcake ones have a standard shape.

2. Is the silicon muffin pans any good?

Usually, the problems that most of the silicon pans have is that they tend to lose their shape and can not distribute the heat properly in the ones. But the ones that come with a metal frame can mitigate both of them completely.

3. Do I need to grease the silicone muffin pans?

As most of the pans will come with non-stick coating, greasing is not absolutely necessary. However, if your pan does not have an efficient coating on it, we would recommend you to grease it.

4. What is the standard well size for the muffin pans?

The standard dimension of the wells is 2.75x2.13x1.38 inches.

5. Can I use a muffin pan for baking cupcakes?

Of course, you will be able to bake cupcakes on these. Other than that, you can also make egg sandwiches, buns, and many other bakery items on it. These are exceptionally versatile.

Final Words

We hope that we were able to make it easier for you to choose the best muffin pan for your baking needs. With that, we would like to conclude here by wishing you good luck and hoping that your muffins turn out delicious and healthy.

Leave a Comment