Top 10 Best Popover Pans: Reviews 2020

Are you a baking enthusiast looking for the perfect baking utensil for popovers? Is a regular muffin pan not doing the job for you? Then fret no more as we bring you the 10 best popover pans money can buy. These baking pan models have some surprising features that are sure to take you by storm!

A perfectly baked cupcake is a delicious addition to any meal. As delicious as they may be, it can be pretty challenging to execute the recipes accurately. With a popover pan, you'll be able to make the most mouthwatering and moist cupcakes and muffins. You can even bake some traditional Yorkshire puddings.

10 Best Popover Pans Review

It’s almost impossible to make the right choice with all the different options these days. So, to clear your clouded judgment, we hope you resort to the following options.

1. Nordic Ware Grand Popover Pan

Nordic Ware Grand Popover Pan

We start off this list with an item that's arguably the best popover pan in the market. It's mostly known for its solid construction and utter reliability. It weighs only 2.2 pounds and is therefore easy to cook with. Maintaining this exclusive popover pan is an absolute breeze.

It hardly takes any effort to clean it due to the specialized material it’s made of. You can cook the most delicious popovers using this pan with an extra level of finesse. The smart dimensions of this pan allow you to bake large muffins as well. This pan’s heat distribution capabilities are what set it apart from others.

The pan is made of heavy cast aluminum, which is the main contributing factor to its even heat distribution. It spreads the heat evenly throughout the muffins so that all the ingredients are perfectly cooked. The heavy cast aluminum also gives the pan a sturdy shape.

It also comes with a non-stick coating, which makes it significantly easier to clean after a baking session. Unlike most manufacturers, they have also included a mild detergent hand wash with the product.

Pros

  • Made of heavy cast aluminum
  • Non-stick coating
  • Easy to use
  • Even heat distribution
  • Hand wash and mild detergent included

Cons

  • Not weighted enough

2. Fox Run 12-Cup Muffin Stainless Steel Baking Pan

Fox Run 12-Cup Muffin Stainless Steel Baking Pan

Coming in at number two, we have the best rated popover pan that can add some variety to your baking recipes. It comes with 12 molds for baking different types of cupcakes and muffins at once. Now you can easily bake large servings more swiftly and efficiently.

This is also one of the most durable baking pans on the market these days. The main reason behind this is its stainless steel body. It’s entirely made of sleek stainless steel with a shine that can last for years. You might already know that this material doesn’t rust easily.

Apart from durability, stainless steel also makes this popover pan lightweight. It has an admirable non-scratch surface that isn't prone to wear. The pan is also stain-resistant, so you hardly have to worry about cleaning it. Even if you do need to clean it thoroughly, it won't have any drastic effects on this pan.

It can endure a good amount of constant scrubbing without ever losing its shine. The stainless steel construction prevents it from reacting with the ingredients you use. Hence, you never have to worry about toxicity. This baking pan can perform surprisingly well under extreme heat.

Pros

  • 12 molds for muffins
  • Made of stainless steel
  • Scratch and stain-resistant
  • Non-reactive
  • Can withstand serious levels of heat

Cons

  • Material is pretty thin

3. Analon Advanced Non Stick Bakeware Popover Pan

Analon Advanced Non Stick Bakeware Popover Pan

This popover pan model certainly deserves to be on this list due to its extreme capacity of resisting heat. It can easily withstand up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit of heat in the oven. Thus, you can quickly cook up several batches of popovers of superior quality. Just make sure you wear mittens to take them out!

Unlike most pans on the market, this model is nonstick both inside and out. This makes sure the popovers are taken out in one piece. Each muffin you bake with this pan will be perfectly shaped and equally scrumptious.

They have also implemented a clever design that can effectively enhance heat distribution. Gone are the days of undercooked muffins and drastically burnt cupcakes. This baking pan efficiently manages the heat to give the popovers a brownish hue. It's something that all bakers long for.

On top of that, it's made of hardened carbon steel that makes it very durable. This high-quality material ensures several years of consistent baking. It also catalyzes the even heat distribution.

Pros

  • Can withstand up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Nonstick both inside and out
  • Evenly distributes heat
  • Batches are very consistent
  • Made of carbon steel

Cons

  • Batches lose consistency after several uses

4. Wilton Giant Jumbo Muffin and Cupcake Pan

Wilton Giant Cupcake Pan

When speaking of popover pans, it’s impossible not to mention this model, which is recommended for its comparatively giant size. The extended dimensions of this cupcake pan will allow you to bake jumbo muffins that taste like heaven. Even the inexperienced bakers can make the most delightful popovers with this pan.

It’s easy to use and easy to maintain. This baking pan has a solid steel construction that enables it to endure extreme amounts of heat. Due to this feature, you can effortlessly bake cupcakes without worrying about burning them. The steel used in its manufacture is also nonstick, so the popovers never cling to the pan.

Hence, it's easy for a beginner to bake with. Besides that, the durable construction allows you to wash it in a dishwasher. It can even withstand vigorous scrubbing without losing its efficiency. Even heat distribution is also one of its remarkable qualities. The batches are always consistent and mouth-watering.

However, the best thing about this pan is that it doesn’t warp under pressure.

Pros

  • No chances of warping
  • Solid steel construction
  • Heat is evenly distributed
  • Can be washed in the dishwasher
  • Highly durable

Cons

  • Relatively pricey

5. Bellemain 6 Cup Non Stick Pan

Bellemain 6 Cup Nonstick Popover Pan

Another addition to this list of reviews is one of the best rated pans on the market. This non-stick baking pan has been specially designed to ensure the maximum rise in cupcakes and muffins.

You can also bake other delicious popovers with this pan. The dimensions of the molds help the popovers rise and make them fluffy.

Similar to the other models on this list, the popover baking pan comes with a nonstick coat that allows the baked goods to slide right out. There is hardly any residue leftover on the pan once you take them out. This also reduces the hassle of cleaning up the pan afterward.

Now, you can put more effort into baking mouth-watering cupcakes and worry less about the maintenance. Besides all that, this high-quality pan is built from welded metal. Needless to say, this makes them extremely durable and long-lasting. Its heat retention capabilities are also pretty remarkable.

It delivers enough heat to the ingredients to make sure the popovers are cooked through and through. You can also leave it in the dishwasher for effortless cleaning.

Pros

  • Made of welded metal
  • Makes the popovers rise vertically
  • Excellent heat retention
  • Can be put inside a dishwasher
  • Effortless maintenance

Cons

  • Relatively pricey

6. Chicago Metallic Professional 6 Cup Popover Pan

Chicago Metallic Professional 6 Cup Popover Pan

As the 6th item on this list, we would like to mention this 6-cup popover pan that allows you to bake a wide variety of popovers. Apart from traditional popovers and cupcakes, you can also bake Yorkshire puddings in this baking pan. It's highly versatile and offers multiple baking uses.

The clever dimensions of this baking pan allow the user to prepare several batches of popovers within a short time. It also makes the popovers airy and soft enough to be admired by all. Once they taste these cupcakes, your customers won't be able to take their minds off of them.

However, the best feature of this pan is that it's made of heavyweight aluminum. This gives the pan a sturdy shape and makes it durable enough to last a long time. The aluminum also offers better heat conduction when baking. Due to the excellent conduction, you can bake the most delicious popovers.

This pan is also silicone-based. Therefore, taking out the cupcakes and muffins is as easy as pie. Even a beginner baking enthusiast can do it with ease.

Pros

  • Can bake a wide variety of popovers
  • Airy and soft popovers
  • Made of heavyweight aluminum
  • Better heat conduction
  • Popovers slide out easily

Cons

  • Coating peels off after several uses

7. Silicone Molds Donut 6 Cup Cupcake Baking Pan

Silicone Molds Donut 6 Cup Cupcake Baking Pan

This next baking pan model is a revolutionary invention in the world of nonstick cookware. Their choice of material and design is unlike any other. This baking pan comes with 6 donut shape molds that make sure the cupcakes retain their shape. The pan is entirely made of LFBG grade silicone.

Also, the materials they used in its construction don’t include additives or plastic fillers. It also makes it significantly easy to slide the popovers right out. Broken cupcakes and sticky residues are a thing of the past.

Moreover, it’s easy to clean them. You can either wash them using soap and water or just leave them in the dishwasher.

Surprisingly, you can even bake brownies and cornbread with the same level of efficiency in this baking pan. It enables you to execute a wide range of recipes. You won’t just be limited to traditional cupcakes and popovers. Each batch you make in this pan is sure to satisfy the consumers to the fullest.

This cupcake baking pan is also easy to use. You don’t need to be an experienced baker to make scrumptious popovers anymore. However, if you feel dissatisfied with its performance, the manufacturer offers full refunds.

Pros

  • Made of LFBG grade silicone
  • No harmful additives or plastic
  • Easy to use
  • Effortless to clean
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Need to keep an eye on the temperature

8. Nordic Ware Cast Aluminum Petite Popover Pan

Nordic Ware Cast Aluminum Petite Popover Pan

Here, we have this delightful little pan with 12 molds for mini popovers. It has a unique design specifically for baking petite cupcakes that cannot be criticized. Don’t be fooled by its size as it offers a whole new level of efficiency. You can quickly make large batches of cupcakes and muffins instantly.

The pan model is made of specialized aluminum, which allows it to endure extreme amounts of heat. It also offers even heat distribution throughout the bite size popovers. The aluminum construction makes the popover lightweight and durable. It can serve for several years without warping under pressure.

They have also added a nonstick coating on the surface that keeps the popovers from sticking to the pan. The muffins remain stable even after they are taken out. You can easily bake tiny cupcakes for parties or occasional events and amaze the guests with your newly acquired baking skills.

This petite pan is entirely made in the USA and passes all the safety regulations. It doesn't include any harmful additives that can tamper with the quality of your baked goods.

Pros

  • 12 petite molds
  • Made of high-quality aluminum
  • Cupcakes remain stable
  • Nonstick coating added
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • Not dishwasher safe

9. USA Pans 6 Well Popover Pan

USA Pans 6-Well Popover Pan

This popover pan is highly recommended for environmentalists as it only uses recycled steel in its construction. It’s made of high-grade aluminized steel, which makes it rigid and lightweight. The manufacturer has only used natural and non-toxic materials to construct this popover pan.

Aluminized steel also offers unmatched heat retention that gives the popovers a brownish hue. This not only makes the baked goods taste heavenly but also makes it look irresistible. The cupcakes are perfectly shaped and stable. They have designed it in such a way that the pan never loses its efficiency.

This all-natural baking pan is coated with a special substance called Americoat. The Americoat is a modified form of silicone coating that makes the pan nonstick. Due to this coating, the baking pan is easy to clean after use.

You hardly need to put any effort into it. It doesn't contain any PTFEs or PFOAs, either, which are harmful if ingested. Each of these pans is manufactured in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, which is enough to ensure its reliability.

Pros

  • Made of all-natural aluminized steel
  • No harmful PTFEs or PFOAs included
  • Coated from top to bottom with Americoat
  • Unmatched heat retention Easy to maintain 

Cons

  • Edges are really sharp

10. Foxrun Linking Popover Pan

Foxrun Linking Popover Pan

Lastly, we would like to mention this exclusive pan that's suitable for baking a wide variety of baked goods. It comes with deep tapered cups that add just the right amount of airiness to the popovers. This makes the cupcakes look more appealing and keeps it soft and moist on the inside.

The outer portions of the popovers are usually crispy due to the dimensions of the baking pan. This is also due to the even heat distribution of the pan, which browns the popovers perfectly. The mouth-watering recipes you can work with are limitless with this pan at your disposal.

What makes it even better is the amount of heat it can endure. This is possible due to the material it's made of. This amazing pan is made from carbon, which has a very high melting point. It's also the main reason for the pan's durability and even heat distribution.

This high-quality material allows you to bake as many cupcakes as you want without warping under the heat. It's also coated with a nonstick substance that's nontoxic. You can easily take out the popovers without ruining their shapes.

Pros

  • Made from carbon steel
  • Distributes heat evenly
  • High durability
  • Nonstick coating
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • The material rusts over time

What to Look for Before Buying?

By now, you know all about the best popover pan models available on the market. However, that's still not enough information to pick the most suitable model for you. Before you delve into making a purchase, there are a few factors you need to consider. These factors will prevent you from putting your money down the drain.

Versatility

The first thing you need to keep in mind when buying a pan is the type of food you want to bake. You can either pick a model that’s extremely versatile or one that can make the perfect popovers only. Muffin pans can give a variety of recipes to choose from when you’re baking.

They are more versatile and enable you to bake all types of food, ranging from traditional cupcakes to delicious Yorkshire puddings. However, a dedicated pan has deeper molds that allow the baked goods to rise up properly. It makes the popovers airy and moist on the inside and crispy on the outside.

The wells are also separated by open frames. This allows the heat to spread evenly throughout the popovers and cook them thoroughly.

Maintenance

This is a crucial factor to consider as it can tell you how much time you'll be spending cleaning the pan. Making cupcakes and muffins is already a time-consuming process. You don't want to pick a pan that needs regular maintenance to stay efficient.

The easiest way to clean baking pans is to put it in the dishwasher. Unfortunately, not all pans are dishwasher safe. If you want to reduce the time required to clean a baking pan, you must buy one that won’t get damaged by a dishwasher.

Type of Material

The type of material a pan is made of is integral for its efficiency. This will tell you how durable the model is. The most durable pans are the ones made entirely from stainless steel. They don't catch rust and are also good at distributing heat evenly.

Nonstick Coating

It’s important that the pan you choose comes with a good nonstick coat that keeps the popovers from sticking to the pan. If your baking pan doesn’t have such coating, the cupcakes and muffins will be ruined when you pop them out. Most of it will be left behind in the pan.

A good nonstick coating is essential because it reduces the cleaning time. The coating should also be nontoxic.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Do I have to use a popover pan?

Although a normal muffin pan can make some satisfactory popovers, it’s recommended to use a dedicated popover pan for that purpose. The deep wells of a pan leave more space for the popovers to rise. It also makes them airy and moist. If you're interested in making popovers, then that's exactly what you need.

2. How do you know when popovers are done?

If you're making popovers, you shouldn't put the pan on the upper or middle rack. The ingredients on the uppermost part will heat up much faster than the rest. This can cause the popover to burn before you're done baking. Put it inside the oven and bake the popovers for 20 minutes with the oven door closed.

After that, reduce the heat to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Then keep baking for another 20 minutes until the popovers are deep golden brown.

3. Can you make a popover batter the night before?

Yes, it's recommended to prepare the batter beforehand so that it's consistent enough. You should mix all the required ingredients in the batter (according to the recipe) and store it inside the refrigerator. Before cooking, take out the batter and let it stay at room temperature for about 30 minutes.

Make sure you stir it thoroughly before pouring it inside the pan.

4. What’s the difference between Yorkshire pudding and a popover?

Popovers are usually coated with butter and baked in muffin pans or popover pans. It uses the same batter as a Yorkshire pudding, but the process is a bit different. A traditional Yorkshire pudding recipe requires the batter to be baked in a special pan. They are usually cooked in pans containing beef drippings.

5. Why do my popovers stick to the pan?

This usually happens when a popover pan does not come with a nonstick coating. You would have to apply some butter before baking to prevent that.

Final Words

As we reach the end of this article, we would like to assure you that you have all the important information you need to pick the best popover pan on the market. Feel free to browse through the different models and assess their features. Don't forget to mull over the key factors as well.

Leave a Comment